Red Light Winter

In the first act, friends Matt, a writer, and Davis, a book editor, are vacationing in Amsterdam. Matt is lonely and suicidal; he is attempting to hang himself when Davis returns to their shared hotel room with Christina. Christina is a prostitute that Davis has hired as a present for Matt. Christina has sex with Matt, although she is more interested in Davis. In the second act, Matt and Davis have returned home to New York City. Christina goes to New York looking for Davis, but finds Matt, who has been obsessed with her since their earlier encounter.

The characters and cast from the 2005 Garage Theatre production are given below; the same cast appeared at the Barrow Street Theatre in 2006.

Chicago Tribune critic Michael Phillips said the premier production was "arresting" and had excellent acting and set design, but was overlong and contained some cliches. When the New York production opened, New York Times critic Charles Isherwood complimented the dialogue and set designs, but complained that there were "too many stale ideas" in the play.

The reviewer for The Daily Telegraph complimented the Ustinov Studio production as interesting and well-acted. The reviewer for The Guardian praised it for "ferociously sharp writing" and "magnetic performances".

Red Light Winter received the Joseph Jefferson Award for Best New Work in 2005 for the Garage Theatre production. The play was nominated for the 2006 Lucille Lortel Award for Outstanding Play. Rapp received the 2006 Obie Award, Special Citation, and Wilmes won an Obie for his performance. Set designer Todd Rosenthal was nominated for a Hewes Design Award. The play was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 2006.